Netflix: the DVD-by-mail company that bet everything on streaming and won

Where Netflix was in 2006

By 2006, Netflix had won the DVD-by-mail rental category against Blockbuster and Walmart. Subscribers paid a flat monthly fee, kept DVDs as long as they wanted, and got the next disc in their queue when they returned the previous one. The business was profitable, growing, and operationally well-run. The competitive pressure had come and gone. Reed Hastings and his team had every reason to keep doing what was working.

They didn't. The strategic insight was that DVD-by-mail was a temporary business. Bandwidth was getting cheaper. Streaming would eventually replace physical media. The company that controlled the streaming-content business in 10 years would not be the same company that controlled DVD-by-mail in 2006 unless Netflix made the pivot itself — on its own timing — instead of waiting for a competitor to force it. Hastings called the strategy “the innovator’s dilemma in reverse”: cannibalize your own business before someone else does it for you.

The pivot, in three difficult phases

Phase 1: Add streaming as a free feature (2007-2010). In January 2007, Netflix launched a streaming service as a free add-on to existing DVD subscribers. Initial library was 1,000 titles, limited to PC viewers. The strategic bet was to get streaming usage into the subscriber base without forcing the business-model shift. Subscribers tried streaming, liked it, and gradually shifted consumption from DVDs to streaming over the next several years. Netflix subscriber count grew from 6.7M to 20M during this phase.

Phase 2: The Qwikster disaster (2011). In July 2011, Netflix announced it would split DVD-by-mail and streaming into separate services with separate pricing — effectively a 60% price increase for subscribers who wanted both. Customer reaction was brutal. Netflix lost 800,000 subscribers in Q3 2011, the stock dropped 77% over the next year, and Hastings spent months publicly apologizing. In September 2011, Hastings announced the DVD business would be renamed Qwikster and run as a separate brand. The backlash was even worse. Within three weeks Netflix reversed the Qwikster decision but kept the price increase. The episode is widely studied as one of the worst corporate-communications failures of the era.

Phase 3: Originals, and the recovery (2013-2017). In February 2013, Netflix released House of Cards — the company's first major original series, made under a $100M production commitment. Then Orange Is the New Black later that year. The originals strategy worked: viewers had something on Netflix they couldn't get anywhere else, which justified the subscription regardless of the licensed-content library competitors were building. By 2017, Netflix originals were a competitive moat that Disney+, HBO Max, and others would spend years trying to match.

What grew, and what came with it

Netflix grew from 6.7M subscribers in 2006 to 280M+ globally by 2026 — one of the most successful business-model pivots in modern corporate history. The original DVD-by-mail business was retired in September 2023, sixteen years after streaming launched. Netflix has expanded into anime, regional originals (Korean K-dramas being a major recent driver), gaming, ad-supported tiers, and password-sharing crackdowns. Market cap reached $300B+ in 2026.

The pivot also remade the entire entertainment industry. Disney+, HBO Max, Peacock, Apple TV+, and Paramount+ all launched in 2019-2021 because incumbents could no longer ignore the streaming model Netflix had created. The streaming wars of the early 2020s, the merger of Warner Bros Discovery, the writers' and actors' strikes of 2023 — all trace back to the disruption Netflix initiated with the 2007 streaming launch.

What other companies tried to learn

The Netflix pivot has been studied across every industry facing technology disruption. The patterns of what other companies learned (and what they failed to learn) are consistent:

• Cannibalize yourself before someone else does. Blockbuster waited; Netflix didn't. Kodak waited; digital camera makers didn't. Most incumbents wait, and most incumbents lose. The companies that survived technology shifts in their categories cannibalized themselves on their own timing.
• Original content is a moat that licensed content isn't. Netflix's originals strategy was the part that competitors couldn't copy quickly. Companies that tried to compete on licensed-content libraries without originals investment found themselves price-pressured and brand-undifferentiated.
• Communication discipline matters as much as strategic discipline. Qwikster showed how the right strategic decision communicated badly can destroy years of customer trust. The communications layer of business-model pivots is the part most companies underestimate.
• Pivots take years, not quarters. The Netflix pivot ran from 2007 (streaming launch) to 2013 (House of Cards) to 2017 (originals as moat) to 2023 (DVD retirement). Each phase was multi-year. Companies that try to pivot in quarters usually produce neither the old business nor the new one.

How RGM thinks about business-model pivots

When clients ask about pivoting their business model, the Netflix case is the structural template. The conditions for the pivot to work are clear: the strategic insight has to be right (Reed Hastings was right about streaming), the company has to commit capital and time to the new business while the old one is still running, leadership has to be willing to absorb the operational and communications mistakes along the way, and the company has to have years to execute. Pivots that try to be cleaner or faster usually don’t produce the same outcomes.

The honest test: would the leadership team make the pivot bet if they were certain the new business would lose money for at least five years before producing returns? If yes, the pivot can run. If no, the company is not ready and the pivot will get killed at the first earnings call where the new business hurts the old one. We tell clients that business-model pivots are organizational decisions, not strategic decisions. The strategy is the easy part. The organizational capacity to absorb the disruption is the hard part, and Netflix had it. Most companies don't.

Frequently asked questions

Related